'Dead Poet's Society' Critique
Name: ___________________ Teacher:
Date : ___________________ Title of Work: ___________________
 
Criteria
Points
1
2
3
4
 
A Teacher Authority/Leadership Position/Teaching Power is attributed to Mr. Keating in 'Dead Poet's Society'.
No mention is made of a teacher authority, leadership position or teaching power.
A leadership position/teaching power is given, with little to no reasoning behind the choice.
A leadership position/teaching power is given, with ample reasoning to support that choice of position/power.
A leadership position/teaching power is given, with ample reasoning and examples to support that choice of position/power.
____
A Classroom Management / Discipline Strategy which Mr. Keating used is identified.
No mention is made of a classroom management / discipline strategy.
A classroom management / discipline strategy is mentioned with little to no reasoning behind the choice.
A classroom management / discipline strategy is given, with ample reasoning to support that choice of strategy.
A classroom management / discipline strategy is given with ample reasoning and examples to support that choice of strategy.
____
A distinction is made about which portion of the 'Dead Poet's Society' is Hollywood and which is reality.
No mention is made of Hollywood versus reality.
A brief reference is made to Hollywood versus reality. (One - two sentences).
A full paragraph is dedicated to the discussion of Hollywood versus reality, with at least one example given.
A minimum of a paragraph is dedicated to the discussion of Hollywood versus reality, with at least three examples given.
____
A rubric is provided with the assignment.
No rubric is provided.
A very basic rubric is provided with simply pass or fail given as options for a minimum of two objectives.
The rubric provided offers at least 4 options(lowest, second, third, highest) per objective to grade the student on.
The rubric provided offers at least 4 options (lowest, second, third, highest) per objective to grade the student on, as well as a specific section for the teacher to make written comments.
____
Citation of sources/works cited.
No citation is provided.
A basic citation is provided, with more than 1 of the sources missing from the citation.
A clear, correct citation is provided, with works cited in APA or MLA format. No more than 1 source is missed.
A clear, correct citation is provided, with works cited in APA or MLA format. All sources are present.
____
       
Total---->
____

Teacher Comments:

 


This rubric is from www.TeacherJet.com